6 Used BMW Models Consumer Reports Gave the ‘Never Buy’ Label

Consumer Reports (CR) has been a source of information for many people who are looking for information on cars. CR has a review of every used car they have. The two most common things they look at is reliability and value. When you are buying a used car, you want to be sure that you are getting the best value for your money. The two most common things CR looks at is reliability and value.

The BMW Is the most expensive vehicle that Consumer Reports has ever tested. It costs $50,000 a piece and retails for more than $100,000. It’s also the best-selling luxury car in the U.S. with almost half a million vehicles sold last year. For many, the BMW Is the car we all aspire to own.

With the number of used car sales hitting an all-time high, Consumer Reports has decided to put a permanent dent in the market with a new series of reports. Titled “Never Buy”, the reports rank a number of different cars based on what CR describes as being “objectively bad”. Although the list won’t impact the already steep price of those vehicles, it will highlight the vehicles that are simply not worth spending money on.. Read more about worst cars to buy 2021 and let us know what you think.

When seeking to purchase a used car from any manufacturer, it may be tough to determine which models are the most dependable. This is due to the fact that dependability ratings may vary significantly from year to year. To assist you, Consumer Reports has prepared a list of used BMW models that you should avoid by labeling them “Never Buy.”

Consumer Reports polled real owners of these cars to create an accurate list of what you can anticipate from your ownership experience. We’ll combine this information with Repair Pal’s maintenance charges to give you an idea of how much these cars will cost you on a yearly basis.

1. BMW X5 (2012-2014) and 2019

BMW X5 | BMW X5 | BMW X5 | BMW X5

Consumer Reports recommends avoiding the X5 as the first used BMW vehicle on this list. Models from 2012 through 2014 and 2019 in particular. This implies there are at least two different generations of the X5. Unfortunately, Consumer Reports does not identify a particular trim level or engine configuration as being the least dependable.

You may choose between two turbocharged six and eight-cylinder engines, depending on which of these two BMW X5 versions you’re looking at.

According to Repair Pal, the yearly maintenance cost for one of these SUVs is approximately $1,185.

BMW X3 (2013, 2015, 2020)

An image of a BMW outdoors, one of the vehicles Consumer Reports gave the 'Never Buy' Label.

BMW X3 | BMW X3 | BMW X3 | BMW X3

The X3 is the next BMW vehicle on Consumer Reports’ list of cars to avoid. Consumer Reports’ list, like the X5, includes many model years, including 2013, 2015, and 2020.

Because the BMW X3 shares its chassis with the 5 Series sedan, it offers a few of the same engine choices. A turbocharged inline four-cylinder and a turbocharged inline six-cylinder are among them.

This SUV will cost you approximately $1,034 per year to maintain, according to Repair Pal. Even though this number is lower than the X5, it is still one of the most costly in its class.

3. BMW X1 (2014 model)

An image of a BMW outdoors, one of the vehicles Consumer Reports gave the 'Never Buy' Label.

BMW X1 | BMW X1 | BMW X1 | BMW X1

Consumer Reports disagrees with you if you think buying the smallest SUV BMW produced in 2014 would save you money on ownership. That’s because the 2014 X1 earned the infamous “Never Buy” designation.

The X1 is built on a sedan chassis, much like the X3, however it’s the smaller 3 Series this time. Despite its tiny crossover body factor, the X1 provides rear-wheel drive, which is one of its better features.

According to Repair Pal, the X1 has the lowest yearly maintenance expenses among the other BMW SUVs on this list, at $915.

4. BMW 5 Series (2011–2013) and 2018

An image of a BMW outdoors, one of the vehicles Consumer Reports gave the 'Never Buy' Label.

BMW 5-Series | BMW 5-Series | BMW 5-Series | BMW 5-Series

While the 5 Series is a stylish car, Consumer Reports believes it is one of the BMW models you should avoid. We’re looking at the 2011-2013 and 2018 model years in particular. If you see any similarities with the aforementioned X3, it’s because many engine components are shared.

The 5 Series, unlike the SUVs listed above, comes in a variety of engine and body type combinations. As a consequence, determining which version is the most trustworthy is much more difficult.

Regardless, Repair Pal predicts that maintaining one would cost approximately $977 per year.

5. BMW 4 Series (2017 model)

An image of a BMW outdoors.

BMW 4-Series | BMW 4-Series

Next on Consumer Reports’ list of used BMW vehicles to avoid is the 4 Series, which is a relatively recent competitor. The 4 Series, which debuted for the 2014 model year, is essentially a two-door variant of the 3 Series sedan. You may have a four-door version of a two-door version of a four-door vehicle if you choose the Gran Coupe.

Surprisingly, Consumer Reports advises against buying only the 2017 model. The 4 Series seems to be one of the most dependable devices on the list, which is intriguing.

Repair Pal is unable to provide any particular information about the 2017 model. A similar 2015 model, on the other hand, costs approximately $1,229 per year to maintain.

BMW 3 Series (2011-2013): 6.

An image of a BMW outdoors.BMW 3-Series | BMW 3-Series

RELATED: Consumer Reports’ Top Midsize Luxury Cars for 2021

Finally, the 3 Series is one of the used BMW vehicles that Consumer Reports recommends avoiding. We’re talking about the 2011-2013 models in particular. These are the years that the F30, the sixth generation of the 3 Series, was introduced.

If you’re asking why these early versions are the most dependable, it’s because by the 2016 model year, the 3 Series had gotten a new engine lineup.

According to Repair Pal, the yearly cost of keeping one of these vehicles operating is approximately $1,030.

Regardless of whatever BMW model you choose, you now have a better idea of which ones you should avoid.

If you are in the market for a new used car, you might want to hold off on choosing a BMW until the next model year. Consumer Reports magazine has published its annual “least-loved cars” list for 2012, and while there are plenty of cars with good reputations that didn’t make it on the list, there are also several BMWs that Consumer Reports thinks should be avoided. Consumer Reports’ favorite is the BMW 320i, which comes with a 2.0-liter inline-four engine that produces 140 horsepower. The 320i is the third-best car in the subcompact executive sedan category.. Read more about worst used cars to buy 2020 and let us know what you think.

This article broadly covered the following related topics:

  • consumer reports cars to avoid
  • worst used cars
  • used cars to avoid
  • worst used cars to buy 2018
  • worst used cars under 5000